 Saint Joseph’s | 1 | S. Ouellette singled. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 1 | C. Sirois flied out to 2b. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 1 | K. Premo struck out. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 1 | S. Picard grounded out to p. |
 Caldwell University | 1 | C. Collins grounded out to 2b. |
| Caldwell University | 1 | Guerra singled. |
| Caldwell University | 1 | Guerra advanced to second on an error by ss. |
| Caldwell University | 1 | T. Davison reached on an error by p; Guerra advanced to third. |
| Caldwell University | 1 | T. Goldych singled, RBI; T. Davison advanced to second; Guerra scored, unearned. |
| Caldwell University | 1 | C. Reiser singled; T. Goldych advanced to second; T. Davison advanced to third. |
| Caldwell University | 1 | E. Leonard singled, RBI; C. Reiser advanced to second; T. Goldych advanced to third; T. Davison scored, unearned. |
| Caldwell University | 1 | M. Chapin doubled, 3 RBI; E. Leonard scored; C. Reiser scored; T. Goldych scored. |
| Caldwell University | 1 | DeAngelis flied out to ss. |
| Caldwell University | 1 | Mi.Goldych reached on an error by 1b; M. Chapin scored, unearned. |
| Caldwell University | 1 | Mi.Goldych advanced to second on a wild pitch. |
| Caldwell University | 1 | C. Collins grounded out to ss. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 2 | H. Liaci struck out. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 2 | A. Ferguson flied out to cf. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 2 | D. Regan singled. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 2 | K. Dowling singled; D. Regan advanced to second. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 2 | J. Osier grounded out to 2b. |
| Caldwell University | 2 | Guerra struck out. |
| Caldwell University | 2 | T. Davison singled. |
| Caldwell University | 2 | T. Goldych singled; T. Davison advanced to second. |
| Caldwell University | 2 | C. Reiser singled, RBI; T. Goldych advanced to second; T. Davison scored. |
| Caldwell University | 2 | E. Leonard doubled, 2 RBI; C. Reiser scored; T. Goldych scored. |
| Caldwell University | 2 | M. Chapin struck out. |
| Caldwell University | 2 | DeAngelis singled, RBI; E. Leonard scored. |
| Caldwell University | 2 | Mi.Goldych struck out. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 3 | S. Ouellette grounded out to ss. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 3 | C. Sirois singled. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 3 | K. Premo reached on a fielder's choice; C. Sirois advanced to second. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 3 | S. Picard lined out to ss. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 3 | H. Liaci struck out. |
| Caldwell University | 3 | D. Regan to 2b. |
| Caldwell University | 3 | K. LaRock to lf for K. Dowling. |
| Caldwell University | 3 | J. Osier to p. |
| Caldwell University | 3 | C. Collins walked. |
| Caldwell University | 3 | Guerra walked; C. Collins advanced to second. |
| Caldwell University | 3 | Guerra advanced to second on a wild pitch; C. Collins advanced to third on a wild pitch. |
| Caldwell University | 3 | T. Davison walked. |
| Caldwell University | 3 | T. Goldych popped up to 2b. |
| Caldwell University | 3 | C. Reiser singled, RBI; T. Davison advanced to second; Guerra advanced to third; C. Collins scored. |
| Caldwell University | 3 | E. Leonard reached on a fielder's choice; C. Reiser advanced to second; T. Davison advanced to third; Guerra out at home 3b to c. |
| Caldwell University | 3 | M. Chapin grounded out to ss. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 4 | A. Ferguson grounded out to p. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 4 | D. Regan reached on an error by ss. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 4 | K. LaRock struck out. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 4 | J. Osier walked; D. Regan advanced to second. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 4 | S. Ouellette singled; J. Osier advanced to second; D. Regan advanced to third. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 4 | C. Sirois flied out to rf. |
| Caldwell University | 4 | DeAngelis reached on an error by ss. |
| Caldwell University | 4 | Mi.Goldych reached on a fielder's choice; DeAngelis out at second ss to 2b. |
| Caldwell University | 4 | Mi.Goldych advanced to second on a wild pitch. |
| Caldwell University | 4 | C. Collins hit by pitch. |
| Caldwell University | 4 | Guerra walked; C. Collins advanced to second; Mi.Goldych advanced to third. |
| Caldwell University | 4 | T. Davison reached on a fielder's choice; Guerra advanced to second; C. Collins advanced to third; Mi.Goldych out at home p to c. |
| Caldwell University | 4 | T. Goldych flied out to 1b. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 5 | K. Premo walked. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 5 | S. Picard singled; K. Premo advanced to second. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 5 | H. Liaci struck out. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 5 | A. Ferguson singled; S. Picard advanced to second; K. Premo advanced to third. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 5 | D. Regan reached on an error by p; A. Ferguson advanced to second; S. Picard advanced to third; K. Premo scored, unearned. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 5 | K. LaRock reached on a fielder's choice; D. Regan advanced to second; A. Ferguson advanced to third; S. Picard out at home 2b to c. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 5 | J. Osier grounded out to 2b. |